


Bits error versus alpha



Bits error versus beta



Bits error versus i
Results
if beta < 1.4918065531878475e+151Initial program 50.8
rmApplied times-frac35.5
Applied associate-/l*35.5
rmApplied div-inv35.6
Applied div-inv35.5
Applied times-frac35.5
Simplified35.5
if 1.4918065531878475e+151 < beta Initial program 62.5
Taylor expanded around inf 49.0
Final simplification37.9
herbie shell --seed 2019021
(FPCore (alpha beta i)
:name "Octave 3.8, jcobi/4"
:pre (and (> alpha -1) (> beta -1) (> i 1))
(/ (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)))
Time bar (total: 4.8m)Debug log
| 41.0ms | 256× | body | 80 | valid |
| 10.0ms | 256× | pre | 80 | true |
| 227.0ms | (/ (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
1 alts after pruning (1 fresh and 0 done)
Merged error: 53.5b
Found 4 expressions with local error:
| 47.2b | (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) |
| 37.3b | (/ (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
| 0.1b | (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) |
| 0.0b | (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 48× | flip-+ |
| 48× | flip3-+ |
| 44× | times-frac |
| 42× | associate-/r/ |
| 38× | add-exp-log |
| 38× | add-cbrt-cube |
| 32× | frac-times |
| 28× | associate-*r/ |
| 25× | add-cube-cbrt |
| 25× | *-un-lft-identity |
| 25× | add-sqr-sqrt |
| 16× | associate-*l/ |
| 14× | associate-/l* |
| 13× | div-exp |
| 13× | cbrt-undiv |
| 11× | pow1 |
| 10× | cbrt-unprod |
| 10× | prod-exp |
| 9× | associate-/l/ |
| 6× | div-inv |
| 6× | associate-*r* |
| 4× | add-log-exp |
| 4× | associate-*l* |
| 4× | associate-/r* |
| 2× | *-commutative |
| 2× | pow-prod-down |
| 2× | distribute-lft-in |
| 2× | frac-2neg |
| 2× | clear-num |
| 2× | distribute-rgt-in |
| 1× | flip-- |
| 1× | pow-prod-up |
| 1× | flip3-- |
| 1× | pow-plus |
| 1× | pow2 |
| 49.0ms | (/ (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
| 37.0ms | (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) |
| 17.0ms | (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 11.0ms | (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) |
| 759.0ms | (/ (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
| 172.0ms | (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) |
| 71.0ms | (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) |
| 49.0ms | (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 873.0ms | (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) |
| 751.0ms | (* (- (* (+ alpha beta) (+ alpha beta)) (* (* 2 i) (* 2 i))) (- (* (+ alpha beta) (+ alpha beta)) (* (* 2 i) (* 2 i)))) |
| 745.0ms | (* (+ (pow (+ alpha beta) 3) (pow (* 2 i) 3)) (+ (pow (+ alpha beta) 3) (pow (* 2 i) 3))) |
| 680.0ms | (/ (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (pow (+ alpha beta) 3) (pow (* 2 i) 3)) (+ (pow (+ alpha beta) 3) (pow (* 2 i) 3)))) (sqrt (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0))) |
| 639.0ms | (/ (* (* (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) (/ (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) (* (* (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0))) |
7 alts after pruning (7 fresh and 0 done)
Merged error: 37.2b
Found 4 expressions with local error:
| 35.5b | (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 34.8b | (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 29.4b | (/ (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) |
| 6.6b | (/ (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) (/ (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) |
| 1416× | times-frac |
| 530× | add-cube-cbrt |
| 530× | *-un-lft-identity |
| 530× | add-sqr-sqrt |
| 186× | associate-/r/ |
| 99× | div-inv |
| 89× | flip-+ |
| 89× | flip3-+ |
| 71× | associate-/r* |
| 34× | add-exp-log |
| 34× | add-cbrt-cube |
| 20× | div-exp |
| 20× | cbrt-undiv |
| 16× | associate-/l* |
| 7× | associate-/l/ |
| 4× | add-log-exp |
| 4× | frac-2neg |
| 4× | clear-num |
| 4× | pow1 |
| 2× | associate-*r/ |
| 1× | flip-- |
| 1× | div-sub |
| 1× | flip3-- |
| 51.0ms | (/ (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) (/ (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) |
| 42.0ms | (/ (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) |
| 19.0ms | (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 8.0ms | (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 836.0ms | (/ (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) (/ (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) |
| 493.0ms | (/ (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) |
| 82.0ms | (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 51.0ms | (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 938.0ms | (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
| 934.0ms | (/ (cbrt (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (cbrt (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) |
| 902.0ms | (/ (/ i 1) (/ (sqrt (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) 1)) |
| 829.0ms | (/ (sqrt (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) (/ (sqrt (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)))) (cbrt (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) |
| 682.0ms | (/ (/ (* (* (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (* (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) (* (* (/ (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) (/ (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) (/ (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0) (/ (+ (* beta alpha) (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i))) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))))) |
8 alts after pruning (8 fresh and 0 done)
Merged error: 37.1b
Found 4 expressions with local error:
| 40.7b | (/ (+ (* (+ i beta) i) (* alpha (+ i beta))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) |
| 40.7b | (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
| 0.2b | (* (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) (/ (+ (* (+ i beta) i) (* alpha (+ i beta))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) |
| 0.0b | (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 34× | add-exp-log |
| 34× | add-cbrt-cube |
| 24× | flip-+ |
| 24× | flip3-+ |
| 20× | associate-/r/ |
| 18× | associate-*r* |
| 14× | add-cube-cbrt |
| 14× | *-un-lft-identity |
| 14× | add-sqr-sqrt |
| 13× | associate-*r/ |
| 13× | frac-times |
| 12× | associate-*l* |
| 12× | times-frac |
| 11× | associate-*l/ |
| 11× | pow1 |
| 10× | cbrt-unprod |
| 10× | prod-exp |
| 10× | div-exp |
| 10× | cbrt-undiv |
| 8× | associate-/l/ |
| 4× | add-log-exp |
| 4× | associate-/l* |
| 4× | div-inv |
| 4× | frac-add |
| 4× | associate-/r* |
| 2× | flip-- |
| 2× | *-commutative |
| 2× | pow-prod-down |
| 2× | flip3-- |
| 2× | frac-2neg |
| 2× | clear-num |
| 1× | pow-prod-up |
| 1× | pow-plus |
| 1× | distribute-lft-in |
| 1× | distribute-rgt-in |
| 1× | pow2 |
| 48.0ms | (* (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) (/ (+ (* (+ i beta) i) (* alpha (+ i beta))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) |
| 35.0ms | (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
| 31.0ms | (/ (+ (* (+ i beta) i) (* alpha (+ i beta))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) |
| 23.0ms | (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 710.0ms | (* (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) (/ (+ (* (+ i beta) i) (* alpha (+ i beta))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))))) |
| 141.0ms | (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
| 82.0ms | (/ (+ (* (+ i beta) i) (* alpha (+ i beta))) (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)))) |
| 42.0ms | (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) |
| 905.0ms | (/ i (sqrt (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0))) |
| 903.0ms | (* (- (* (+ alpha beta) (+ alpha beta)) (* (* 2 i) (* 2 i))) (- (* (+ alpha beta) (+ alpha beta)) (* (* 2 i) (* 2 i)))) |
| 730.0ms | (+ (* (* (- (* i i) (* beta beta)) i) (- i beta)) (* (- i beta) (* alpha (- (* i i) (* beta beta))))) |
| 610.0ms | (/ (+ (+ alpha beta) i) (sqrt (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0))) |
| 609.0ms | (* (+ (pow (+ alpha beta) 3) (pow (* 2 i) 3)) (+ (pow (+ alpha beta) 3) (pow (* 2 i) 3))) |
8 alts after pruning (7 fresh and 1 done)
Merged error: 37.1b
Found 4 expressions with local error:
| 40.7b | (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
| 35.4b | (sqrt (+ (* (+ i beta) i) (* alpha (+ i beta)))) |
| 35.4b | (sqrt (* (+ i alpha) (+ beta i))) |
| 0.4b | (/ (sqrt (* (+ i alpha) (+ beta i))) (+ (* 2 i) (+ beta alpha))) |
| 22× | sqrt-div |
| 19× | flip-+ |
| 19× | flip3-+ |
| 17× | add-sqr-sqrt |
| 16× | add-cube-cbrt |
| 16× | *-un-lft-identity |
| 15× | times-frac |
| 10× | associate-/l/ |
| 10× | associate-*r/ |
| 8× | sqrt-prod |
| 8× | add-exp-log |
| 8× | associate-*l/ |
| 8× | add-cbrt-cube |
| 8× | frac-times |
| 6× | associate-/r* |
| 5× | associate-/l* |
| 4× | add-log-exp |
| 4× | associate-/r/ |
| 4× | frac-add |
| 4× | pow1 |
| 2× | div-inv |
| 2× | div-exp |
| 2× | pow1/2 |
| 2× | frac-2neg |
| 2× | clear-num |
| 2× | cbrt-undiv |
| 1× | flip-- |
| 1× | flip3-- |
| 1× | rem-sqrt-square |
| 20.0ms | (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
| 12.0ms | (/ (sqrt (* (+ i alpha) (+ beta i))) (+ (* 2 i) (+ beta alpha))) |
| 4.0ms | (sqrt (+ (* (+ i beta) i) (* alpha (+ i beta)))) |
| 1.0ms | (sqrt (* (+ i alpha) (+ beta i))) |
| 121.0ms | (/ (* i (+ (+ alpha beta) i)) (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0)) |
| 87.0ms | (sqrt (+ (* (+ i beta) i) (* alpha (+ i beta)))) |
| 82.0ms | (/ (sqrt (* (+ i alpha) (+ beta i))) (+ (* 2 i) (+ beta alpha))) |
| 82.0ms | (sqrt (* (+ i alpha) (+ beta i))) |
| 709.0ms | (sqrt (+ (* (* (- (* i i) (* beta beta)) i) (- i beta)) (* (- i beta) (* alpha (- (* i i) (* beta beta)))))) |
| 592.0ms | (/ (+ (+ alpha beta) i) (sqrt (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0))) |
| 589.0ms | (/ i (sqrt (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0))) |
| 585.0ms | (/ (+ (+ alpha beta) i) (cbrt (- (* (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i)) (+ (+ alpha beta) (* 2 i))) 1.0))) |
| 547.0ms | (sqrt (* (+ i alpha) (- (* beta beta) (* i i)))) |
8 alts after pruning (6 fresh and 2 done)
Merged error: 37.1b
49.7% (1.4b remaining)
Error of 37.9b against oracle of 36.5b and baseline of 39.2b
| 1.7s | 8000× | body | 80 | valid |
| 377.0ms | 8000× | pre | 80 | true |