


Bits error versus c0



Bits error versus A



Bits error versus V



Bits error versus l
Results
if (* V l) < -3.334876225266701e+183 or -1.175718995950725e-219 < (* V l) < 1.98613222286689e-309 or 4.4098284317428e+306 < (* V l) Initial program 37.3
rmApplied associate-/r*24.9
rmApplied add-cube-cbrt25.2
Applied sqrt-prod25.2
Applied associate-*r*25.2
rmApplied div-inv25.1
Applied cbrt-prod25.1
rmApplied cbrt-div25.1
Applied cbrt-div15.3
Applied frac-times15.3
Applied sqrt-div12.0
Simplified12.0
if -3.334876225266701e+183 < (* V l) < -1.175718995950725e-219Initial program 6.8
rmApplied clear-num7.1
if 1.98613222286689e-309 < (* V l) < 4.4098284317428e+306Initial program 9.7
rmApplied div-inv9.7
Applied sqrt-prod0.4
Final simplification6.2
herbie shell --seed 2019016 +o rules:numerics
(FPCore (c0 A V l)
:name "Henrywood and Agarwal, Equation (3)"
(* c0 (sqrt (/ A (* V l)))))
Time bar (total: 14.6s)Debug log
| 601× | (pre true 80) |
| 305× | (body nan 80) |
| 296× | (body real 80) |
| 6.0ms | (* c0 (sqrt (/ A (* V l)))) |
1 alts after pruning (1 fresh and 0 done)
Merged error: 21.9b
Found 3 expressions with local error:
| 18.5b | (sqrt (/ A (* V l))) |
| 4.3b | (/ A (* V l)) |
| 1.6b | (* c0 (sqrt (/ A (* V l)))) |
| 8× | sqrt-prod |
| 7× | associate-*r* |
| 7× | add-sqr-sqrt |
| 6× | add-cube-cbrt |
| 6× | *-un-lft-identity |
| 3× | add-log-exp |
| 3× | div-inv |
| 3× | log1p-expm1-u |
| 3× | add-exp-log |
| 3× | add-cbrt-cube |
| 3× | pow1 |
| 3× | expm1-log1p-u |
| 2× | sqrt-div |
| 1× | *-commutative |
| 1× | associate-*r/ |
| 1× | pow1/2 |
| 1× | frac-2neg |
| 1× | associate-/r* |
| 1× | clear-num |
| 1× | rem-sqrt-square |
| 4.0ms | (* c0 (sqrt (/ A (* V l)))) |
| 2.0ms | (sqrt (/ A (* V l))) |
| 1.0ms | (/ A (* V l)) |
| 63.0ms | (* c0 (sqrt (/ A (* V l)))) |
| 33.0ms | (sqrt (/ A (* V l))) |
| 22.0ms | (/ A (* V l)) |
| 6.0ms | (sqrt (* (cbrt (/ A (* V l))) (cbrt (/ A (* V l))))) |
| 6.0ms | (sqrt (sqrt (/ A (* V l)))) |
| 5.0ms | (sqrt (sqrt (/ A (* V l)))) |
| 5.0ms | (cbrt (sqrt (/ A (* V l)))) |
| 5.0ms | (sqrt (sqrt (/ A (* V l)))) |
11 alts after pruning (11 fresh and 0 done)
Merged error: 13.7b
Found 3 expressions with local error:
| 18.5b | (sqrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 3.8b | (/ (/ A V) l) |
| 1.6b | (* c0 (sqrt (/ (/ A V) l))) |
| 8× | sqrt-prod |
| 8× | add-sqr-sqrt |
| 7× | add-cube-cbrt |
| 7× | associate-*r* |
| 7× | *-un-lft-identity |
| 4× | associate-/l* |
| 4× | div-inv |
| 3× | add-log-exp |
| 3× | log1p-expm1-u |
| 3× | add-exp-log |
| 3× | add-cbrt-cube |
| 3× | pow1 |
| 3× | expm1-log1p-u |
| 2× | sqrt-div |
| 1× | associate-/l/ |
| 1× | *-commutative |
| 1× | associate-*r/ |
| 1× | pow1/2 |
| 1× | frac-2neg |
| 1× | clear-num |
| 1× | rem-sqrt-square |
| 8.0ms | (/ (/ A V) l) |
| 4.0ms | (* c0 (sqrt (/ (/ A V) l))) |
| 2.0ms | (sqrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 36.0ms | (* c0 (sqrt (/ (/ A V) l))) |
| 34.0ms | (sqrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 22.0ms | (/ (/ A V) l) |
| 10.0ms | (sqrt (* (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)))) |
| 9.0ms | (sqrt (sqrt (/ (/ A V) l))) |
| 7.0ms | (sqrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 6.0ms | (sqrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 6.0ms | (sqrt (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l))) |
12 alts after pruning (11 fresh and 1 done)
Merged error: 8.5b
Found 4 expressions with local error:
| 21.0b | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 21.0b | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 21.0b | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 7.2b | (sqrt (* (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)))) |
| 12× | cbrt-prod |
| 7× | add-cube-cbrt |
| 7× | *-un-lft-identity |
| 7× | cbrt-div |
| 7× | add-sqr-sqrt |
| 4× | add-log-exp |
| 4× | log1p-expm1-u |
| 4× | add-exp-log |
| 4× | add-cbrt-cube |
| 4× | pow1 |
| 4× | expm1-log1p-u |
| 3× | div-inv |
| 3× | sqrt-div |
| 3× | pow1/3 |
| 1× | sqrt-prod |
| 1× | associate-*r/ |
| 1× | associate-*l/ |
| 1× | pow1/2 |
| 1× | rem-sqrt-square |
| 1× | frac-times |
| 2.0ms | (sqrt (* (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)))) |
| 1.0ms | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 1.0ms | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 1.0ms | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 126.0ms | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 124.0ms | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 123.0ms | (sqrt (* (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)))) |
| 113.0ms | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 416.0ms | (exp (* 1/3 (- (+ (log (/ 1 l)) (log (/ 1 V))) (log (/ 1 A))))) |
| 411.0ms | (exp (* 1/3 (- (+ (log (/ 1 l)) (log (/ 1 V))) (log (/ 1 A))))) |
| 398.0ms | (exp (* 1/3 (- (+ (log (/ 1 l)) (log (/ 1 V))) (log (/ 1 A))))) |
| 385.0ms | (exp (* 1/3 (- (+ (log (/ 1 l)) (log (/ 1 V))) (log (/ 1 A))))) |
| 201.0ms | (* (exp (* 1/3 (- (+ (log (/ -1 V)) (log (/ -1 l))) (log (/ -1 A))))) (cbrt -1)) |
13 alts after pruning (12 fresh and 1 done)
Merged error: 8.5b
Found 4 expressions with local error:
| 21.0b | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 21.0b | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 11.1b | (cbrt (/ A V)) |
| 7.2b | (sqrt (* (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)))) |
| 12× | cbrt-prod |
| 7× | add-cube-cbrt |
| 7× | *-un-lft-identity |
| 7× | cbrt-div |
| 7× | add-sqr-sqrt |
| 4× | add-log-exp |
| 4× | log1p-expm1-u |
| 4× | add-exp-log |
| 4× | add-cbrt-cube |
| 4× | pow1 |
| 4× | expm1-log1p-u |
| 3× | div-inv |
| 3× | sqrt-div |
| 3× | pow1/3 |
| 1× | sqrt-prod |
| 1× | associate-*r/ |
| 1× | associate-*l/ |
| 1× | pow1/2 |
| 1× | rem-sqrt-square |
| 1× | frac-times |
| 2.0ms | (sqrt (* (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)))) |
| 1.0ms | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 1.0ms | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 0.0ms | (cbrt (/ A V)) |
| 118.0ms | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 106.0ms | (sqrt (* (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)))) |
| 92.0ms | (cbrt (/ (/ A V) l)) |
| 63.0ms | (cbrt (/ A V)) |
| 466.0ms | (exp (* 1/3 (- (+ (log (/ 1 l)) (log (/ 1 V))) (log (/ 1 A))))) |
| 384.0ms | (exp (* 1/3 (- (+ (log (/ 1 l)) (log (/ 1 V))) (log (/ 1 A))))) |
| 380.0ms | (exp (* 1/3 (- (+ (log (/ 1 l)) (log (/ 1 V))) (log (/ 1 A))))) |
| 230.0ms | (* (exp (* 1/3 (- (+ (log (/ -1 V)) (log (/ -1 l))) (log (/ -1 A))))) (cbrt -1)) |
| 227.0ms | (exp (* 1/3 (- (log (/ 1 V)) (log (/ 1 A))))) |
12 alts after pruning (11 fresh and 1 done)
Merged error: 4.4b
78.5% (1.5b remaining)
Error of 6.2b against oracle of 4.7b and baseline of 11.7b
| 17798× | (pre true 80) |
| 8941× | (body real 80) |
| 8857× | (body nan 80) |